I have just re-discovered the low-tech Leicaphilia blog of Timothy Vanderweert and his personal writing about film and digital photography. , what Vanderweert I learned that Vanderweert died in July 2023 from cancer, but thankfully, his wife has kept his Wordpress blog online so we can still read it. Leicaphilia's combination of image and text that reminds us yet again of how few are the blogs by photographers that interweave good photographs and insightful writing about photography and are in it for the long haul.
A number of Vanderweert posts on Leicaphilia are concerned with various experiments to compare digital black and white photos to those made with fast and grainy b+w film, such as Kodak Tri-X films and various digital attempts to emulate the Tri-X film look or emulate an HP5 negative. I personally think that is going down a rabbit hole. Why try to make digital look like film for though these are the same (photography) they are also different. The uses of photographs are different, the cultural impacts are different, the way they're made is different. Why not accept the differences between the film and digital technologies and the historical differences between the two eras/centuries and get on with digital photography?
The industrial world that film photography was a part of is long gone. That means turning away from the legacy ecosystem, then accepting and working with what Vanderweert characterises as the transparent, ultra-lucidity of digital files, their noiseless purity, lack of grain and what some see as a certain lack of presence or sterility. We have a new, albeit flawed photography.
No doubt, the technology of a digital B&W photography will improve as the resources of the industry are applied to overcoming that plastic look too often seen with digital B&W files. Eventually, the resources will pay off with an appealing graduated tonality emerging in digital B&W photography.
Reading Vanderweert's blog made me wonder if there were any other similar Leica blogs on the internet, that is ones involving writing about photography. Unfortunately, there are no links on the legacy Leicaphilia blog for me to follow up. It is very much a stand alone blog. The similar blogs, if they existed, probably have come and gone --- 99 per cent of new blogs die within their first year, primarily due to their failure to attract a significant number of readers. Even Still Searching, that was backed by Fotomuseum Winterthur, has packed it in.